The Franklin Era Ends: Analysis of James Franklin’s Firing and Penn State’s Uncertain Future

October 12, 2025: The Day Penn State Football Changed Forever

On a crisp Sunday afternoon in October, Penn State athletic director Pat Kraft made the decision that would send shockwaves through college football: James Franklin was fired as head coach, effective immediately. This marked the first in-season coaching change at Penn State since 2011 and the end of a decade-long era that brought both unprecedented success and, ultimately, disappointing decline.

The Timing: Why Now?

Franklin’s dismissal came just one day after a devastating 22-21 home loss to Northwestern, a defeat that dropped Penn State to 0-4 in Big Ten play and 3-5 overall. The timing, while shocking, was calculated:

Key Factors Leading to the Decision:

1. Complete Collapse in Big Ten Play

• 0-4 conference record after a 3-0 non-conference start
• Losses to ranked opponents (Oregon, Ohio State)
• Upset defeats to UCLA and Northwestern as heavy favorites
• Inability to compete with elite Big Ten programs

2. The Northwestern Loss: The Final Straw

The 22-21 defeat to Northwestern was particularly damning:

• Penn State was a 21.5-point favorite at home
• Drew Allar suffered a season-ending injury in the fourth quarter
• It marked Northwestern’s first win over Penn State since 2015
• The loss occurred on Senior Day, adding emotional weight to the defeat

3. Recruiting Concerns

• 2026 recruiting class beginning to slip
• Top recruits expressing uncertainty about program direction
• Negative momentum affecting long-term roster building

4. Fan and Donor Pressure

• Season ticket renewal rates declining
• Major donors expressing concerns about program trajectory
• Social media sentiment at historic lows

Franklin’s Legacy: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

The Good (2014-2022)

Franklin arrived in 2014 with immediate success:

• 2016: Big Ten Championship, Rose Bowl appearance
• 2017: Fiesta Bowl victory over Washington
• 2019: 11-2 season, Cotton Bowl appearance
• 2022: 11-2 season, Rose Bowl victory over Utah
• Multiple top-10 finishes
• First Penn State coach since Joe Paterno to win 11+ games multiple times

Recruiting Excellence:

• Consistently ranked in top-15 recruiting classes
• Developed NFL talent at multiple positions
• Established Penn State as a national recruiting destination

The Decline (2023-2025)

The final three seasons showed clear regression:

• 2023: 7-6 record, first losing season since 2015
• 2024: 9-4 record, close losses in big games
• 2025: 3-5 record when fired, worst start since 2004

Key Issues in Final Years:

• Inability to win big games against elite competition
• Offensive inconsistency despite talented personnel
• Questionable game management and clock usage
• Staff turnover and coaching instability

The Terry Smith Era: Interim Leadership

With Franklin’s dismissal, defensive backs coach Terry Smith was appointed interim head coach for the remainder of the 2025 season.

Smith’s Background:

• Penn State alum and former player (1985-1988)
• NFL coaching experience (Chicago Bears, Washington)
• College coaching experience (Temple, Rutgers)
• Highly respected as a recruiter and developer of defensive backs

Interim Coach Performance (as of November 7, 2025):

• 0-2 record (Iowa loss by 1, Ohio State loss by 24, Indiana loss by 24)
• Close competitive loss to Iowa showed potential
• Struggles against elite competition continued
• Maintained player morale during difficult transition

The Search for Penn State’s Next Head Coach

The hiring process for Penn State’s next permanent head coach will be critical for the program’s future. Athletic Director Pat Kraft faces enormous pressure to make the right choice.

Key Considerations for the Search:

1. Offensive Philosophy

Penn State needs modernization on offense. The next coach must bring:

• Up-to-date offensive schemes
• Strong quarterback development track record
• Ability to maximize talented skill position players

2. Big Ten Experience

• Understanding of Big Ten recruiting landscape
• Experience competing against Ohio State, Michigan, Oregon
• Regional recruiting connections

3. Cultural Fit

• Understanding of Penn State’s unique culture and traditions
• Commitment to academic standards
• Ability to handle pressure of a high-profile program

4. NFL Development Track Record

• History of developing NFL-caliber players
• Proven ability to recruit and develop elite talent
• Understanding of modern college football landscape

Potential Candidates (Speculative):

• Current Power 5 Coaches with proven success
• Top Offensive Coordinators from elite programs
• NFL Coaches with college experience
• Penn State Alumni with coaching credentials

Impact on Current Players

The coaching change has significant implications for current players:

Immediate Effects

• Roster Uncertainty: Players considering transfer options
• Recruiting Impact: 2026 commits reconsidering decisions
• Development Concerns: Disruption in player development cycles

Long-term Considerations

• NFL Draft Preparation: Seniors concerned about draft stock
• Position Changes: New coaching staff may prefer different players
• Academic Planning: Players considering transfer eligibility

Key Players Affected:

• Drew Allar: NFL draft decision impacted by coaching uncertainty
• Kaytron Allen: Elite running back with NFL potential
• Nicholas Singleton: Talented sophomore running back
• Devonte Ross: Senior receiver needing strong finish

Financial Implications

Franklin’s firing carries significant financial consequences:

Buyout Details

• Contract Remaining: 3 years, $21 million total
• Buyout Clause: Estimated $10-12 million
• Assistant Coach Contracts: Additional $3-5 million in buyouts

Program Costs

• Search Firm Fees: $250,000+ for head coaching search
• New Coach Salary: Likely $7-10 million annually
• Staff Retention Bonuses: Incentives to keep key assistants

Total Estimated Cost: $20-25 million for complete coaching transition

Historical Context: Comparing to Previous Penn State Coaching Changes

2011: The Joe Paterno Era Ends

• Circumstances: Sandusky scandal aftermath
• Timing: End of regular season
• Interim Coach: Tom Bradley
• Permanent Hire: Bill O’Brien

2025: The Franklin Era Ends

• Circumstances: Performance-based firing
• Timing: Mid-season (unprecedented since 1930s)
• Interim Coach: Terry Smith
• Permanent Hire: TBD

Key Differences:

• Modern college football landscape (NIL, transfer portal)
• Higher financial stakes and expectations
• More intense media scrutiny
• Recruiting complexities in transfer portal era

The Road Ahead: Immediate and Long-term Challenges

2025 Season Challenges

• Bowl Eligibility: Must win final 3 games (highly unlikely)
• Player Retention: Preventing mass transfer exodus
• Recruiting Class: Maintaining 2026 recruiting momentum
• Team Morale: Keeping players engaged through difficult season

2026 and Beyond

• Cultural Rebuilding: Restoring confidence in program
• Recruiting Reset: Establishing new recruiting identity
• Competitive Restoration: Competing with Ohio State, Oregon, Michigan
• Facility Investments: Maintaining competitive advantages

Fan and Alumni Reactions

The Franklin firing has generated diverse reactions across the Penn State community:

Supporters of the Decision

• “Change was necessary for program’s future”
• “Franklin had plateaued and couldn’t win big games”
• “New energy needed to compete with Ohio State”

Critics of the Timing

• “Mid-season firing was unfair to players”
• “Should have waited until season’s end”
• “Creates instability during crucial recruiting period”

Franklin’s Legacy Defenders

• “Franklin restored program after sanctions”
• “Multiple 11-win seasons and major bowl wins”
• “Deserved chance to finish season”

National Perception and Media Coverage

The national media has closely covered Franklin’s firing:

Major Storylines:

• Big Ten Coaching Carousel: High-profile coaching change in elite conference
• Program Decline: From playoff contender to sub-.500 in one season
• Coaching Market Impact: Franklin’s availability affects other openings
• Penn State’s Future: National questions about program direction

Expert Analysis:

• Many analysts saw Franklin’s firing as inevitable
• Questions about Penn State’s ability to attract elite replacement
• Speculation about program’s place in new Big Ten hierarchy

Lessons Learned: What This Means for College Football

For Athletic Directors

• Patience vs. Performance: Balancing long-term vision with immediate results
• Coaching Contracts: Importance of buyout clauses and flexibility
• Timing Considerations: When to make difficult coaching decisions

For Coaches

• Job Security: Even established coaches face increasing pressure
• Program Building: Challenges of maintaining elite status
• Adaptation: Need to evolve with changing college football landscape

For Programs

• Cultural Identity: Importance of maintaining program values during transitions
• Recruiting Stability: Managing recruiting during coaching uncertainty
• Competitive Balance: Challenges of competing in resource-rich conferences

Conclusion: A New Chapter for Penn State Football

James Franklin’s firing marks the end of a significant era in Penn State football history. His tenure brought both unprecedented success and, ultimately, disappointing decline. The decision to fire him mid-season reflects the high expectations and pressure that come with leading one of college football’s elite programs.

The path forward for Penn State will require:

• Strategic Hiring: Finding the right leader for modern college football
• Patience and Support: Allowing new coach time to implement vision
• Cultural Continuity: Maintaining Penn State’s unique identity
• Competitive Investment: Resources needed to compete at highest level

The Franklin era’s end creates both challenges and opportunities. While the immediate future looks uncertain, Penn State’s tradition, resources, and passionate fan base provide a foundation for future success.

The next head coach will inherit a talented roster, passionate fan base, and the challenge of restoring Penn State to its place among college football’s elite programs. The decisions made in the coming months will shape Penn State football for the next decade.

One thing is certain: Penn State football will never be the same after the 2025 season. The Franklin era is over, and a new chapter is about to begin.

---

Analysis current as of November 7, 2025

All information sourced from official Penn State announcements, reputable sports journalism outlets, and verified program records